I need some advice, and I would love the community here to offer me some wisdom! I am a woman in my mid-twenties, and my mechanical pulmonary valve is now almost ...Read more
I need some advice, and I would love the community here to offer me some wisdom! I am a woman in my mid-twenties, and my mechanical pulmonary valve is now almost 8 years old. Last month, I met with my cardiologist for my twice-per-year check-up. After reviewing my EKG and ultrasound from that day, he told me that my valve is deteriorating slowly as expected, but I have now officially entered the wide window of time where I could reasonably have surgery for a valve replacement. He said he hopes that my heart can wait another year before I get the surgery (because doing so would help reduce the number of surgical interventions I will need in the next sixty years), but he said it can be nearly impossible for any medical tests to determine when or if my heart will deteriorate rapidly over the next year. He said that my personal symptoms and experience need to be the main determining factor of when I choose to get surgery. So now I am faced with the scary choice of choosing when to get the new valve. My symptoms do not impede my life for now, and I am exercising as my doctor encouraged me to so that I can be more in-tune with my heart. But now it is my responsibility to choose when I should have my valve replacement. What would you do in my place; would you wait until you noticed your heart deteriorating rapidly to increase your long-term benefits, would you choose to have the surgery earlier than you feel you need it just to avoid any danger to yourself, or would you do something else entirely?
(The photo is a picture of me on my 25th birthday last month. A quarter century with a CHD!)
Rose Madura Hi Jessica. I'm glad you have reached out to this forum for advice. You are so young to be dealing w ... Read more
Rose Madura Hi Jessica. I'm glad you have reached out to this forum for advice. You are so young to be dealing with this but it seems it's always been part of your life. My first advice would be a second opinion from a very reputable hospital who has good experience with a situation like yours. Maybe even a third opinion. I wish you the best. You are a beautiful young lady. Please keep us posted on your journey.
J Alexander Lassally Great pic and story. Maybe similar to above... Get a few opinions on timing suggestions... Make sure ... Read more
J Alexander Lassally Great pic and story. Maybe similar to above... Get a few opinions on timing suggestions... Make sure your meds are maximized to stretch things out.... And by all means get to the very best centers / surgeons out there. Are you with a super high volume surgeon now?
One interesting point is what you want the opinion of cardiac surgeons as well as cardiologist about timing. I found cardiac surgeons to be WAY MORE dialed into the nuances of surgery than the cardiologists who were back office dudes.
I'd say you want to be with Cleveland Clinic, Mayo, Mt Sinai - one of the greats to maximize all of this. It is worth the effort!!! Best of luck.
Richard Munson Not sure what that meal is but suddenly i am hungry.
Jessica F Rose and J, thank you so much for your advice! Taking responsibility for my own medical decisions has ... Read more
Jessica F Rose and J, thank you so much for your advice! Taking responsibility for my own medical decisions has been admittedly quite daunting these past few years, but I'm becoming more ready to dive in headfirst now. My previous surgeon was a pediatric surgeon, so I likely need to find someone new. Thank you for your suggestions, I'll use them to get some other opinions on when a valve replacement would be best for my health. I appreciate your support and I will definitely make more posts when I have updates! And Richard, I also get hungry every time I think of that steak!
Fidel Martínez Ruiz If you were 70 years old, I´d tell you: right away to the operating room! . But with 25, I would wa... Read more
Fidel Martínez Ruiz If you were 70 years old, I´d tell you: right away to the operating room! . But with 25, I would wait a while, having regular check-ups and monitoring how you feel making moderate exercise, such as your doctor told you .
Jessica F Thank you for your advice, Fidel! Yes, because of my age I think this situation is a bit of a balanci ... Read more
Jessica F Thank you for your advice, Fidel! Yes, because of my age I think this situation is a bit of a balancing act.
Sean Adkins I would get a virtual second opinion from Cleveland Clinic
John Cook I don’t know why a year now makes a dramatic difference on long term replacement strategy over the ... Read more
John Cook I don’t know why a year now makes a dramatic difference on long term replacement strategy over the next 60 years. I’d want that explained.
I agree with getting a second opinion.
Kathryn Kirsh Hi Jessica, I would wait if it were me. But we all have individual decisions to make. I wish the best ... Read more
Kathryn Kirsh Hi Jessica, I would wait if it were me. But we all have individual decisions to make. I wish the best for you.
Allen Carkner Hello Jessica, Welcome! My name’s Allen.
I wanted to reach out and share a bit from my experience, since I'm also in my mid twenties with a history of valve surgery. I had my Ross Procedure, for aortic stenosis, two and a half years ago when I was 24, so the whole process of monitoring and decision-making is still very fresh for me. From my understanding, it’s often wise to push a valve replacement, especially when you're young, until it's truly the right time. The key thing I've learned is that the "right time" isn't just about waiting until you feel terrible with severe symptoms. A huge piece of the puzzle for the doctors is the objective data they get from MRIs and echocardiograms. They're closely watching for signs of strain on your heart, particularly looking for right ventricle hypertrophy or enlargement. This is where having a fitness routine is such a brilliant way to evaluate things yourself. If you’re consistent, you get your own objective data. You might notice your heart is slowing you down just a bit or that your recovery is taking longer. ... Read more
Allen Carkner Hello Jessica, Welcome! My name’s Allen.
I wanted to reach out and share a bit from my experience, since I'm also in my mid twenties with a history of valve surgery. I had my Ross Procedure, for aortic stenosis, two and a half years ago when I was 24, so the whole process of monitoring and decision-making is still very fresh for me. From my understanding, it’s often wise to push a valve replacement, especially when you're young, until it's truly the right time. The key thing I've learned is that the "right time" isn't just about waiting until you feel terrible with severe symptoms. A huge piece of the puzzle for the doctors is the objective data they get from MRIs and echocardiograms. They're closely watching for signs of strain on your heart, particularly looking for right ventricle hypertrophy or enlargement. This is where having a fitness routine is such a brilliant way to evaluate things yourself. If you’re consistent, you get your own objective data. You might notice your heart is slowing you down just a bit or that your recovery is taking longer.
That’s exactly what happened in my case. I had managed aortic valve stenosis my entire life, getting an echocardiogram annually or every other year. The final decision was made when a failed stress test and some critical echocardiogram values lined up with the notable but subtle symptoms I was starting to feel. Once that objective data was clear, things moved very quickly—I was in surgery within two months of that failed stress echo.
It seems counterintuitive at first, but you can really only have a few sternotomy procedures before it starts getting more dangerous. Every year you can safely buy with your current valve is incredibly valuable. The key word is "safely"—meaning waiting, but not so long that your right ventricle sustains damage.
Lifetime management of valve disease is key. It's a long-term strategy that you, your family, and your doctors will navigate together, based on the hard data from scans, how you're feeling, your life expectancy, and the lifestyle you want to lead. Sorry for my whole novel, I like to share what I’ve picked up along the way. Since I now have a donor pulmonary valve, I will almost certainly need an intervention in the next 20-30 years or sooner. I plan on two transcather valves to get me to maybe my late 50s or 60s meaning valve in vale procedures potentially then a potential open heart procedure to do a full replacement. I thought through this timeline with my surgeon and cardiologist before my valve replacement as the lifetime management portion of the conversation. Please message me if you have any questions. I’m not a doctor so I don’t wan this to be taken as medical advice just some tips from my own personal experience.
Susan Bodner Jessica I would wait until you totally feel right about the timing. Being a for lifer heart patient I ... Read more
Susan Bodner Jessica I would wait until you totally feel right about the timing. Being a for lifer heart patient I think we are very in tune with our bodies and sometimes we just seriously know when we know. There are also so many things going on in the heart valve world that a year could make a big difference in what's available for you. I am almost 63 and when I had to help my valve surgery it was actually a phone call from the insurance lady telling me that they were changing my Coverage from 100% to 95% by June 30. That was 35 years ago and it was that little bit of information that helped me make a good decision. I pray you make the best decision for you so you can live the best to the rest of your life be blessed
Yesterday, my friends and I attended the Adult Congenital Heart Association's awareness walk in Austin. The organization held it at a beautiful park near the ...Read more
Yesterday, my friends and I attended the Adult Congenital Heart Association's awareness walk in Austin. The organization held it at a beautiful park near the children's hospital, and the weather was both cool and sunny for the few hundred people who showed up to walk. My friends' faces are covered here for privacy, but I promise they really are smiling! 😄 All three of us in this photo each have a variation of heart disease, although I am the only one who has had a valve replacement. It feels great to support each other like this and to meet others who truly understand what it's like to live with a heart condition.
susan harris thank you so much for posting. i had no idea this organization existed! will look for a group in phi ... Read more
susan harris thank you so much for posting. i had no idea this organization existed! will look for a group in philadelphia!
Jessica F Susan it's a great organization with lots of wonderful resources! Their website shows that they have... Read more
Jessica F Susan it's a great organization with lots of wonderful resources! Their website shows that they have a walk in the Philadelphia area in June.
susan harris my son and i are signed up for silver springs near him and i might do the philly one (it turns out it ... Read more
susan harris my son and i are signed up for silver springs near him and i might do the philly one (it turns out it is literally in my back yard - who knew?)
I got a call from my cardiologist yesterday evening. He said that, based on the results of a cardiac stress test I did a few weeks ago, he wants to try and ...Read more
I got a call from my cardiologist yesterday evening. He said that, based on the results of a cardiac stress test I did a few weeks ago, he wants to try and get another year or two out of my current artificial valve before undergoing a replacement surgery. This news brought me a sigh of relief, knowing the procedure is further off than anticipated. At the same time, I feel a bit of dread. I am blessed with relatively good health, but how I wish my heart valve trouble could be a one-time fix rather than a lifelong companion! It is hard to always prognosticate the next surgery and the next. I know there are many who feel the same and that knowledge does bring me comfort.
Robert Miller I assume artificial valve means a tissue valve rather than a mechanical valve. I wish you all the bes ... Read more
Robert Miller I assume artificial valve means a tissue valve rather than a mechanical valve. I wish you all the best.
Pamela Gregory I knew about my AVR for 10 years before it was done and it was mental torture for me. I am trying my... Read more
Pamela Gregory I knew about my AVR for 10 years before it was done and it was mental torture for me. I am trying my best to have a much different attitude this time and even though I know I will need another replacement in the hopefully long off future, to enjoy each day, keep close connections with friends and family, and live life to the fullest
Robert Miller Living your life to the fullest and with a meaningful purpose is always the best attitude, no matter ... Read more
Robert Miller Living your life to the fullest and with a meaningful purpose is always the best attitude, no matter what. Good for you!
In the days and weeks post-op in 2017, part of my recovery was teaching myself (with the help of Bob Ross) to paint. I find that painting is emotionally healing ...Read more
In the days and weeks post-op in 2017, part of my recovery was teaching myself (with the help of Bob Ross) to paint. I find that painting is emotionally healing for me; I tend to practice more of it during difficult periods of my life. Here is one of my favorite paintings I did in the month after my surgery about 7 years ago.
Sue Lambkin Beautiful and calming. Imagine able to do that 1 month after surgery. This painting is meaningful to ... Read more
Sue Lambkin Beautiful and calming. Imagine able to do that 1 month after surgery. This painting is meaningful to you, but also to me. My story goes back 40 years ago after my husband had an accident when he was 38., he will now be 80. With my operation coming, I was repeatedly humming....Lord, this time you gave me a ⛰️ mountain. Beautiful. ❤️Sue
Kimberly Eisenhut Very beautiful and so wonderful you found something to help you
Jessica F Sue and Kimberly, thank you for your very kind and touching words! I think easy-going hobbies can be ... Read more
Jessica F Sue and Kimberly, thank you for your very kind and touching words! I think easy-going hobbies can be good sources of peace during recovery. Sue, I will be praying for peace for you and your family this week as you approach your procedure!
Richard Munson Omg, bob ross. I used to love him on tv painting. He is up there someplace looking down on that “ p ... Read more
Richard Munson Omg, bob ross. I used to love him on tv painting. He is up there someplace looking down on that “ pretty little tree. “. He has quite a personal story as well.
Richard Munson I’m so old i remember jon gnagy on t.v and my mother bought me my first jon gnagy coloring kit. My ... Read more
Richard Munson I’m so old i remember jon gnagy on t.v and my mother bought me my first jon gnagy coloring kit. My mind wanders.
Michael Ponzio Beautiful painting. Majestic. God bless you.
Andrew Dial This is absolutely amazing. Thank you for sharing
Rose Madura Very beautiful. Bob Ross was awesome. And you are too!
Bob Le Vaillant What a lovely, serene painting. Well done...
Dr. Luis Castro is a world-renowned heart valve surgeon that has performed thousands of heart valve operations that include minimally-invasive techniques.
(The photo is a picture of me on my 25th birthday last month. A quarter century with a CHD!)
One interesting point is what you want the opinion of cardiac surgeons as well as cardiologist about timing. I found cardiac surgeons to be WAY MORE dialed into the nuances of surgery than the cardiologists who were back office dudes.
I'd say you want to be with Cleveland Clinic, Mayo, Mt Sinai - one of the greats to maximize all of this. It is worth the effort!!! Best of luck.
I agree with getting a second opinion.
I wanted to reach out and share a bit from my experience, since I'm also in my mid twenties with a history of valve surgery. I had my Ross Procedure, for aortic stenosis, two and a half years ago when I was 24, so the whole process of monitoring and decision-making is still very fresh for me.
From my understanding, it’s often wise to push a valve replacement, especially when you're young, until it's truly the right time. The key thing I've learned is that the "right time" isn't just about waiting until you feel terrible with severe symptoms. A huge piece of the puzzle for the doctors is the objective data they get from MRIs and echocardiograms. They're closely watching for signs of strain on your heart, particularly looking for right ventricle hypertrophy or enlargement.
This is where having a fitness routine is such a brilliant way to evaluate things yourself. If you’re consistent, you get your own objective data. You might notice your heart is slowing you down just a bit or that your recovery is taking longer.
... Read more
I wanted to reach out and share a bit from my experience, since I'm also in my mid twenties with a history of valve surgery. I had my Ross Procedure, for aortic stenosis, two and a half years ago when I was 24, so the whole process of monitoring and decision-making is still very fresh for me.
From my understanding, it’s often wise to push a valve replacement, especially when you're young, until it's truly the right time. The key thing I've learned is that the "right time" isn't just about waiting until you feel terrible with severe symptoms. A huge piece of the puzzle for the doctors is the objective data they get from MRIs and echocardiograms. They're closely watching for signs of strain on your heart, particularly looking for right ventricle hypertrophy or enlargement.
This is where having a fitness routine is such a brilliant way to evaluate things yourself. If you’re consistent, you get your own objective data. You might notice your heart is slowing you down just a bit or that your recovery is taking longer.
That’s exactly what happened in my case. I had managed aortic valve stenosis my entire life, getting an echocardiogram annually or every other year. The final decision was made when a failed stress test and some critical echocardiogram values lined up with the notable but subtle symptoms I was starting to feel. Once that objective data was clear, things moved very quickly—I was in surgery within two months of that failed stress echo.
It seems counterintuitive at first, but you can really only have a few sternotomy procedures before it starts getting more dangerous. Every year you can safely buy with your current valve is incredibly valuable. The key word is "safely"—meaning waiting, but not so long that your right ventricle sustains damage.
Lifetime management of valve disease is key. It's a long-term strategy that you, your family, and your doctors will navigate together, based on the hard data from scans, how you're feeling, your life expectancy, and the lifestyle you want to lead. Sorry for my whole novel, I like to share what I’ve picked up along the way. Since I now have a donor pulmonary valve, I will almost certainly need an intervention in the next 20-30 years or sooner. I plan on two transcather valves to get me to maybe my late 50s or 60s meaning valve in vale procedures potentially then a potential open heart procedure to do a full replacement. I thought through this timeline with my surgeon and cardiologist before my valve replacement as the lifetime management portion of the conversation. Please message me if you have any questions. I’m not a doctor so I don’t wan this to be taken as medical advice just some tips from my own personal experience.
Sue