Hey everybody!
One of the most frequent questions I am asked when talking to future heart valve surgery patients and their caregivers is, “What is the death rate of heart valve surgery?”.
It’s a morbid question. But, as I have written about before (See “Disspelling The Fear Of Heart Valve Surgery?”), the statistics are overwhelmingly positive. And, the statistics continue to get better.
That said, I just reviewed a unique study that makes some interesting observations about the death rates of heart bypass and heart valve procedures. I thought you might want to review some of the latest statistics specific to the success and failure of bypass surgery.
So you know, I cover each of the topics below in the new revision of my book, The Patient’s Guide To Heart Valve Surgery.
From Pennlive.com:
The in-hospital death rate for coronary bypass surgery patients declined in 2005, while the rates of readmission increased slightly during the same period, according to a new report on cardiac operations in Pennsylvania.
The 2005 mortality rate among bypass patients was 1.9 percent, down from nearly 2 percent the previous year and from 2.4 percent in 2000, the Pennsylvania Health Care Cost Containment Council said in the report released today.
At the same time, 5.5 percent of bypass patients were readmitted within seven days of being discharged — up from 5.2 percent — and 13.6 percent were readmitted within 30 days of being discharged, up from 13.2 percent. Heart failure, infections and abnormal heart rhythms were the top three reasons for readmissions (see “Heart Valve Surgery Complications”).
The council, a quasi-governmental agency that monitors hospital finances and performance, has published annual reports on bypass surgeries and how much hospitals charge for them since 1992.
This year, it added information on heart-valve procedures, which are more invasive and complicated than bypasses, and included payment data on both procedures for the first time.
The information on valve surgery was added because bypass surgeons were telling the council that the number of operations they performed were “dropping dramatically,” while the number of heart-valve surgeries was increasing, Volavka said.
Bypass patients using private insurers remained hospitalized for nearly six days after surgery on average, with payments for the full hospital stay averaging $30,247, while Medicare patients stayed for nearly eight days and paid $29,175. (See “The Costs Of Heart Valve Surgery”) Patients who had both procedures at once had the longest post-surgery hospital stays and highest average payments.
Of the 17,331 patients who had one or both surgeries, 755 patients, or more than 4 percent, contracted infections during their hospital stays.
Carolyn F. Scanlan, president and CEO of the Hospital and Healthsystem Association of Pennsylvania, noted that the report does not take into account factors such as a patient’s vulnerability to contracting an infection in the hospital, such as diabetics.
Here is a look at midstate hospitals:
Both Holy Spirit Hospital and Harrisburg Hospital had higher-than-expected in-hospital mortality rates in 2005 for patients who underwent coronary artery bypass surgery.
Harrisburg Hospital had a higher-than-expected mortality rate for patients who had the bypass surgery and died within 30 days after being discharged. Data for Harrisburg Hospital also showed higher-than-expected readmission rates for patients within seven days and 30 days after discharge.
Penn State Milton S. Hershey Medical Center had mortality and readmission rates that were in line with expectations.
Dr. Dana Kellis, chief medical officer at PinnacleHealth System, parent of Harrisburg Hospital, noted that the council’s data is for 2005, when the hospital had “significant turnover” in its surgical staff. Since then, the hospital has made some “significant” changes to improve the quality of care for heart patients, he said.
For example, Kellis said readmission rates have been reduced by a half to two-thirds.
In a statement issued from Holy Spirit, Dr. Joseph A. Torchia, chief medical officer, said the hospital participates in the Society for Thoracic Surgery national database, and the most recent results for January through June 2006 show the hospital’s mortality rate at 2.1 percent, better than its peer group and the national mortality rate of 2.3 percent.
Torchia said Holy Spirit ranks as one of the nation’s top hospitals for providing fast emergency care to heart attack patients. “Nationally, only a third of hospitals meet the 90-minute goal for treating heart attack patients, and we beat that by a significant margin,” he said.
Adam Pick is the author of The Patient’s Guide To Heart Valve Surgery, a unique book which integrates the clinical facts of heart valve surgery with the personal experiences of an actual heart valve surgery patient. This special book was designed to minimize stress and enhance the patient’s recovery. To learn more about Adam’s heart valve surgery book, click here.